Journal of Research in Architecture & Planning
NED University of Engineering & Technology

ISSN 2519-5050 (Online), ISSN 1728-7715 (Print)
Listed in HEC recognized Y category Journal
Journal DOI: www.doi.org/10.53700/jrap_neduet
Listed in Ulrich Periodicals Directory, Scientific Indexing Services & Cross Ref.
   


Previous Volumes

   
DISSONANT HERITAGE AND THE HAZARDS OF RETENTION

  Jon Calame

Article DOI: www.doi.org/10.53700/jrap3012021_2

ABSTRACT


Finally, after years of negotiation and fundraising, a Confederate monument in Athens, Georgia (USA) – decorated with fresh flowers – was ready for public dedication. Many supporters, along with clergy and local politicians, were in attendance. Just as a solemn speech had begun, though, a local newspaper records the sudden arrival of a violent storm as “wind, rain and lightning… suddenly burst forward in great fury. (Merton,1956 : 30-247). The assembly scattered momentarily, then carried on in a nearby Baptist church. It was the first of many storms which would swirl around this memorial to Athens’ Civil War dead.

These words were let it be:

Bright Angels come and Guard our Sleeping Heroes



… which may ring strangely to our years now, it being unusual, even in a literary context, to compare the dead with the sleeping. Were these simple poetic indulgences, or did the monument’s designers intend to suggest that their object represented something more… something which was then merely dormant, temporarily defeated, but capable of being awoken to a new life? Was the true purpose of the monument to gaze forward in anticipation of this awakening, rather than to look back in reverence?

This paper will explore a few divergent contemporary interpretations of these controversial objects in the public domain, tracing the lineage of motivation leading some call for their protection and others to call for their removal.

Keywords:

Heritage, Monuments, Confederate State
Volume 30 Issue 1
ISSN (P) 1728-7715 - ISSN (E) 2519-5050
Issue DOI: www.doi.org/10.53700/jrap3012021
 
Download
 
 
 
 
 
 
 


All articles published by JRAP are licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. This permits anyone to copy, redistribute, remix, transmit and adapt the work provided the original work and source is appropriately cited.